| Objective 3: |
Humane Society of Indianapolis Is this organization cursed? Or is it somehow dooming itself? On July 31, 2008, the Humane Society of Indianapolis (HSI) announced the appointment of John Aleshire to replace Martha Boden as Director. HSI’s performance under Boden’s leadership was pockmarked with scandal and obfuscation:
More about these and other occurrences can be viewed in a letter to the Better Business Bureau questioning an “Ethics Award” bestowed on the agency. It was hoped that more noble behavior would characterize the “new” HSI. The new HSI has a new director, new friends, an attractive website that boasts “Love Awaits,” and the ever-present fund-raising emphasis. Sadly, we see that the community is being hoodwinked yet again. A dangerous precedent was set on July 25, 2009, when HSI hosted a clandestine meeting with a few, select animal welfare “partners:” Indy Feral (IF), Indy Pit Crew, FIDO, and City County Councilor Angela Mansfield (an IF volunteer) as well as other city-county councilors and city representatives to discuss IACC and its new administrator Doug Rae. No one directly connected with IACC was invited, yet IACC was the topic. From that secret meeting came a rapid sequence of annoyances and new rules for the newly appointed administrator Rae, barely seven months on the job. Rae was given a 60-day probationary period and "improvement plan" of union-mandated bullet points by which he had to abide. These included such things as returning to the union their break room, which was being used to kennel sick but treatable animals, and requiring updates and meetings with a union representative and Acting Public Safety Director Mark Renner, neither of whom would make themselves available for Rae to hold such required meetings. At the end of that 60-day probationary period, Rae was dismissed on October 5th and his management team of four soon followed; five committed individuals who were just beginning to making a difference for the animals at the municipal shelter. A sad consequence of HSI hosting this meeting is the embarrassment it brings to local animal welfare efforts and the loss of respect for an agency that had been working itself out of a self-destructive identity. As a local animal welfare observer noted, “The thought of the animals suffering is bad enough, but what REALLY burns me is the elbow-rubbing and the back-scratching WITHOUT REGARD FOR THE ANIMALS! Why does ‘power’ lure consciences away from doing the right thing? Those that succumb to it and feign concern are worse than those who neglect outright!” It appears that HSI continues to be about HSI, manipulating image and public perception. Actions don’t match the wordsFrom Indiana Business Journal, February, 4, 2009: “Aleshire is trying to reassure donors that HSI is fulfilling its mission, and hoping the money will follow. ‘We are the Humane Society of Indianapolis… We must take seriously our role as the leader in animal welfare issues.’ ” “Aleshire’s plan is heavy on public relations.” “In the meantime, the Humane Society on January 1, 2009, will begin to spay and neuter animals from Indianapolis Animal Care and Control. ‘We can do it faster, and we can do it cheaper,’ declared HSI board chair David Horth.” “The city’s shelter has a higher kill rate, and animal welfare activists have alleged maltreatment and mismanagement. Aleshire took the relationship a step further, announcing on October 28, 2008 that the Humane Society would no longer go to shelters outside Marion County to stock its adoption floor. Instead, he would look to Harding Street to fill the gaps.” But what really happened? “We must take seriously our role as the leader in animal welfare issues.” David Horth is the HSI board chairman and also sits on the IACC advisory board. For HSI to host a private meeting to discuss Rae’s performance presents a potential conflict of interest when Mr. Horth should have been supporting the IACC administrator as an IACC board member. Since he seemed unwilling to do that, Mr. Horth could have resigned from the IACC board. At the very least, this meeting should not have been hosted at the HSI facility. Has Mr. Aleshire attended an IACC advisory board meeting prior to Rae’s premeditated dismissal? No. The last scheduled IACC board meeting before Rae’s dismissal (Sept. 9) was an opportunity for Rae and his management team to share the progress that was being made at the agency. Instead, according to IACC board secretary Erin Pratt, Horth announced that he would not attend, and the meeting was cancelled due to lack of a quorum. The rescheduled board meeting Sept. 23 was again cancelled because Horth declared he would not be present. Coincidence? A press conference was held on October 5th to announce Rae’s dismissal. Standing behind Acting Public Safety Director Mark Renner, who spoke for 13 minutes about reasons for Rae’s termination, were David Horth, HSI director John Aleshire, and Lisa Tudor of Indy Feral, who all supported the termination. Media coverage can be viewed here and here. This is how agents behave who, “…must take seriously our role as the leader in animal welfare issues?” “Aleshire’s plan is heavy on public relations.” Public relations have always been a heavy focus of HSI. Public relations are not a bad thing, but it must be backed with honest, noble actions or it will backfire. “In the meantime, the Humane Society on Jan. 1, 2009, will begin to spay and neuter animals from Indianapolis Animal Care and Control. ‘We can do it faster, and we can do it cheaper,’ declared HSI board chair David Horth.’ The number of animal sterilized and returned to the IACC adoption floor according to Doug Rae?” “ZERO.” “The city’s shelter has a higher kill rate, and animal welfare activists have alleged maltreatment and mismanagement. Aleshire took the relationship a step further, announcing October 28, 2008 that the Humane Society would no longer go to shelters outside Marion County to stock its adoption floor. Instead, he would look to Harding Street to fill the gaps.” Last year, approximately 100 animals a month were pulled by HSI from IACC. According to the community relations manager (also terminated promptly after Rae’s dismissal), the number of animals pulled from HSI had dropped to as low as 6 to 8 per month. One of the points used to illustrate Rae’s performance was the decrease in animals getting out of the shelter compared to last year. When a sister agency (HSI) has decided to again import animals from outside the county (Tipton, IN) - contrary to what it had indicated - instead of helping the animals at the overwhelmed municipal shelter in its own community where six out of ten are being killed, what else would be the consequence? Coincidence? Under the previous IACC administration, all rescue groups entered through the back door, selected the animals of their choosing and were gone. Record keeping was poor, and reconciliation of animals’ numbers and their disposition was a disaster. To correct this, Rae’s administration asked that these rescue organizations follow a simple procedure of calling IACC prior to arrival and checking in at the front desk—a procedure that was welcomed by the majority of the organizations but HSI chose to disregard. Repeated requests to comply by the community relations manager were ignored. HSI agents’ visits to IACC became less frequent and when they did arrive, shelter workers experienced an attitude of arrogance and ownership. Also used to discredit Rae was the claim that the agency was killing ear-tipped cats, an accusation driven by HSI partner Indy Feral. These claims were never substantiated, just said to be so. Although Rae repeatedly asked for confirmation of kennel numbers and dates, such information was never provided by those making the accusations. But the accusations continued from the HSI “partner.” Sadly, the effort to oust Rae and four others was successful. All indications point to an orchestrated campaign of HSI partners and individuals who could not tolerate being unable to dictate to the new IACC administration what to do and how to do it. Once again, IACC is under the control of a political appointee, and within 24 hours it was back to business as usual. That is the status quo — a sorry setback for the animals and those who truly care for their welfare. What is about to happen with IACC? Privatization? When the question of privatization was posed at the October 14th IACC advisory board meeting, Mr. Horth claimed he knew nothing about privatization. One week later on October 21st, WTHR-TV is reporting about IACC privatization. Story is here. Who will be awarded an IACC contract? Follow the money. And once again, open disclosure of the Humane Society of Indianapolis has become an issue. |
 |
Check back soon!
|
 |
 |
|
Raise money for Friends of Indianapolis Animal Care and Control Foundation just by searching the web and shopping online!
|